Amber Alert (2024)

 

**This post contains spoilers**

The Story- Charlotte (Ducky Branson) is kidnapped on a playground in broad daylight in front of her mother, Monica (Katie McClellan) and her grandmother, Gail (Claire Slemmer), lured into a car by a man and a doll. Elsewhere in the same area, Jaq (Hayden Panettiere) misses her rideshare car. Jaq convinces Shane (Tyler James Williams), another rideshare driver, to accept a large tip for a ride.

Eventually, Jaq spots a Toyota Camry that matches the description for Charlotte’s Amber Alert. Jaq, Shane, Monica, Sergeant Phil Casey (Kevin Dunn), and an emergency dispatcher named Cici (Saidah Arrika Ekulona) all work together to rescue Charlotte. Aaron (Kurt Oberhaus), the driver of the Camry, claims he’s innocent, but Jaq realizes something is off, when she learns the truth about the license plate number. 

My Thoughts- The remake for Amber Alert is a good example for why it’s not so easy to make a found-footage film. Amber Alert 2012 took the found-footage approach, and when you compare that film to the 2024 remake, the problems for the 2012 original are more obvious. The big one? Recording when there’s no real reason to record anything during long stretches of the movie. I’ll even go as far as saying the car chase scenes, or the scenes, where Jaq and Shane are following Aaron are easily more exciting. There’s a more uneasy and believable feeling that anything could happen at any moment. A big difference compared to the found-footage film, where the main idea basically is, let’s keep following Muller, while we wait to see what he does next. 

The 2024 remake is a more polished and refined film by a long shot. The story has structure, the characters have more depth, and all the other loose screws are tightened up, including smoother storytelling, better pacing, and it’s a more consistently tense film. I could actually buy into Jaq and Shane’s reasons for wanting to save Charlotte, if we’re comparing the two to Samantha and Nate (mainly Samantha) from the original. Shane is a father, and you can tell he loves and cares about his son. Jaq is still heartbroken about the tragedy involving her baby boy, so it’s easy to go along with a thought process, where she probably believes she couldn’t save her son, but there’s a chance she can save Charlotte.

There’s some callbacks and similarities to the original. The gas station, Jaq dropping her earbud in the backseat, so she can hear what’s going on inside the car, and the confrontation with Aaron in the open field. A few tweaks and some minor changes, but it’s still easy to see some connections to the 2012 film.

So Aaron is the bad guy. Okay. Not a big surprise, and they made things more obvious for the big reveal in the remake. Going back to that scene in the open field, where Jaq and Shane faked having car troubles, you can clearly see Aaron was ready to kill them, while their backs were turned. That, and his story about Charlotte being his daughter was completely phony. Also, it doesn’t help that you can actually see Charlotte in the backseat, when Aaron drives away. 

Still, Amber Alert manages to deliver a satisfying finale. Aaron’s house of horrors? Some genuinely creepy stuff. It’s not just limited to keeping Charlotte in a cage. The video camera, the room decorated to resemble a little girl’s room, the shoes from all the girls he kidnapped outside, the scrapbooks, and Aaron’s bizarre obsession with dolls and dressing his deceased victims as dolls. You really get to see how Aaron is a disgusting and vile creep, a man with a disturbing dark side.

Jaq and Shane survive with some help from Sergeant Casey, Casey kills Aaron, and Charlotte is reunited with Monica. Comparing the two films, the remake decided to go with the happy ending. Yes, certain events were a little bit too convenient. Casey shows up at the exact moment, when Aaron was seconds away from killing Jaq? But that final shot with Charlotte and Monica embracing, while Jaq, still wounded on a stretcher, has a smile on her face, when she sees both of them together really works as a feel good moment. 

The chemistry between Hayden Panettiere and Tyler James Williams is excellent. They did a good job of playing off of each other, with a bold and somewhat reckless Jaq pushing a reluctant Shane to continue the pursuit. Williams and Panettiere are convincing as two ordinary people, who stumbled into a dangerous problem, and there’s a handful of funny moments from Jaq and Shane during the chase.

Is Amber Alert perfect? No. The story mainly goes through the motions step by step. The twists and the attempted swerves were easy enough to predict, but Amber Alert is still an effective mystery/thriller. The reveal for the house of horrors and the unpleasantness behind the villain’s dolls completely changes the mood towards the end, taking a dark turn just when you believe things couldn’t possibly get any worse. 

As the story unfolds, you also realize it’s not so easy to put out a successful Amber Alert. The accuracy, crucial details, including a license plate number, are all important factors. Add in the fact that dispatchers will be flooded with calls that might or might not help, AND if the perpetrator is driving a common or popular car (e.g. the Toyota Camry here), the odds of saving a kidnapped victim could swing in either direction. And what’s going to happen, when the suspect realizes they’re on the radar and the clock is ticking?

A big upgrade over the 2012 original, featuring solid performances from Hayden Panettiere and Tyler James Williams, and of course, Kevin Dunn delivers with the strong presence of a veteran actor. And kudos to Saidah Arrika Ekulona for playing her role well, as the concerned dispatcher, who’s trying to help Monica and Charlotte. The 2012 original’s ending was bleak and shocking. But the remake takes a more joyous and upbeat approach to close out the movie, and overall, it’s a rare case, where the remake definitely outshines the original. 

Rating- 6/10